Insurance Services for Pennsylvania & Ohio – All in One Place

Rodgers & Co Insurance is your one-stop independent insurance agency located in Mercer County, serving individuals, families, and small businesses across Northwestern Pennsylvania and Northeastern Ohio. Whether you're protecting a home, a business, or your next big adventure, we make it easy to compare coverage from top carriers and choose what fits—without the hassle.

Personal Insurance That Fits Real Life

We help you protect the things that matter most with policies tailored to your needs, not a sales quota. Our team works with individuals and families across Pennsylvania and Ohio to match the right coverage with your budget and lifestyle.

Explore our personal insurance options
Black front-view car icon on a white background

Auto

Insurance

Get reliable coverage for your car, truck, or teen driver, with multi-car and safe driver discounts available.

Black silhouette of a motorcycle with rider on a white background

Motorcycle

Insurance

Protection for bikes, gear, and riders—whether cruising Mercer County or touring through Ohio.

Black sailboat icon with waves below

Boat

Insurance

Seasonal or year-round coverage for pontoons, fishing boats, jet skis, and more.

Black camper van icon with roof rack and windows

RV

 Insurance

Insurance built for the road and the campground. Great for towables and motorhomes alike.

Black house icon with a white door and chimney

Homeowners

Insurance

Coverage for your home, belongings, and liability—customized for homes in our region.

Black outline icon of a person with a key, symbolizing access or account security

Renters

Insurance

Affordable protection for tenants—cover your stuff and your liability in an apartment or rental home.

Black apartment building icon with multiple windows and a central door

Condo

Insurance

Fill the coverage gaps left by your HOA’s master policy with the right protection for your unit and belongings.

Black house icon above wavy water lines, indicating flooding or flood hazard

Flood Insurance

Because standard home insurance doesn’t cover water damage from floods.

Black umbrella icon above a shield with a white checkmark

Umbrella Insurance

Extra liability protection when your home or auto policy isn’t enough.

Hands holding a black heart with a white heartbeat line icon

Life Insurance

Term & whole life policies designed to protect your family’s financial future.

Black outlined plus sign icon on a white background

Health Insurance

Term & whole life policies designed to protect your family’s financial future.

Commercial Insurance That Covers More Than the Basics

From local shops to regional contractors, Rodgers & Co helps business owners across Western PA and Eastern OH find coverage that’s smart, affordable, and scalable.


We offer solutions for:

Black umbrella over contract and dollar coin icon, suggesting insurance or financial protection.

Commercial Insurance › 
General liability, property, and more for small to midsize businesses.

Black icon of a gear over a dollar bill, suggesting cost or pricing settings

Workers’ Compensation Insurance › 
Keep your team protected and meet state requirements.

Black car silhouette on a white background

Commercial Auto Insurance ›
Coverage for company vehicles, trailers, and fleets.

Black briefcase icon with a handle and clasp

Business Owners Policies (BOP) ›
Combine key protections into one convenient, cost-saving plan.

Don’t see what you need? Reach out—we also offer access to specialty commercial carriers for hard-to-place industries.



Why Work with an Independent Insurance Agency?

Unlike online-only services or company-specific agents, we don’t work for just one provider. That means we shop multiple carriers—like Auto-Owners, Progressive, Westfield, Safeco, and others—to find the best value for your specific needs.


What makes us different:

Black check mark on a white background

Local advice from licensed agents who live where you do

Black check mark on a white background

One place to compare auto, home, business, and life insurance

Black check mark on a white background

Family-run and community-based since 2001

Black check mark on a white background

Personalized support during claims—not just when you sign up

Don’t see what you need? Reach out—we also offer access to specialty commercial carriers for hard-to-place industries.

Serving Western PA & Eastern Ohio with Straight Answers and Local Experience

We’re proud to serve families and businesses from Sharon to New Castle, from Hermitage to Youngstown. If you're in Mercer County, Lawrence County, or across the border in Trumbull or Mahoning County, we're here to help you make sense of your coverage—and maybe even save you some money while we’re at it.

Your Questions, Answered

  • Do you offer bundled discounts for home and auto insurance?

    Yes! Bundling home and auto with the same carrier can lower your rates significantly. We’ll quote both together and show you how the savings stack up.

  • Can you help with business insurance for newer companies?

    Absolutely. We regularly work with startups and small businesses that are insuring their first location, vehicle, or crew. We’ll guide you through what’s required and what’s smart.

  • I live in Pennsylvania but work in Ohio—can you still help?

    Yes. We understand cross-border coverage needs and will make sure your auto, home, or business policies meet the right state’s requirements without overcomplicating things.

  • What carriers do you work with?

    We represent several respected insurance companies including Auto-Owners, Progressive, Westfield, Safeco, Millville Mutual, and more. This means you’re not stuck with just one option.

  • Do you offer Medicare or health insurance plans?

    Yes—we offer Medicare supplement plans, individual health coverage, and life insurance. Visit our Life & Health Insurance page › to learn more.

Smiling child between two adults outdoors, both leaning in to kiss her cheeks in warm sunlight
Older woman and child rolling dough on a floured table in a bright kitchen

Let’s Get Started

Whether you're shopping for your first policy or reviewing what you already have, our team is ready to help. Contact us to ask a question or use our simple quote tool to start comparing rates today.