About Rodgers & Co Insurance
Local Service & Experience You Can Trust
If you’re looking to learn more about Rodgers & Co Insurance, here’s what matters most: we’re not a corporate chain. We’re a local, family-owned insurance agency in West Middlesex, PA, built from scratch to serve our community with honesty, experience, and a no-pressure approach.
We’ve spent decades helping our neighbors across Northwestern Pennsylvania and Northeastern Ohio—and just over the border in Youngstown, Hubbard, and throughout Trumbull and Mahoning Counties—find the right coverage at the right price.
Built from the Ground Up, Right Here in Western Pennsylvania
Rodgers & Co Insurance was founded in 2001 by [Owner’s Name], who brought over 23 years of experience with Erie Insurance and a desire to build something independent, personal, and rooted in the community. Starting with zero clients, we grew the agency through word of mouth, one policy and one referral at a time.
Today, we remain a trusted independent insurance agency in Pennsylvania offering real solutions for real people. Whether you're looking for auto, home, business, or life insurance, we help you compare options across multiple carriers—and we always take the time to explain what your policy actually covers.
What We Believe In: Real Help, Not Hard Sales
We keep things simple on purpose. We believe that great insurance service means:
Being clear and direct.
No jargon, no gimmicks—just answers.
Putting relationships first.
Our clients aren’t numbers. We know their names, families, and stories.
Balancing cost and coverage.
We’ll help you reduce risk and waste—not just premiums.
Supporting the community.
Our agency reflects the small-town values of Western PA and Eastern Ohio.
As an experienced insurance team in West Middlesex, we’re proud to be known for doing the right thing, even when it takes more time. That’s just how we do business.
Rooted in the Region, Committed to Local Needs
We’re based in West Middlesex, just a few miles south of I-80 and a stone’s throw from the Ohio line. That puts us in a unique position to serve clients across state lines—especially those who live in Pennsylvania and work in Ohio (or vice versa). We understand the coverage differences, regulations, and regional concerns that affect local drivers, homeowners, and business owners.
Whether you're in Sharpsville, New Castle, Hermitage, or downtown Youngstown, Rodgers & Co is your
local insurance agent with the flexibility and experience to help across the board.
Reach Out Today
Whether you’re shopping for your first policy or reviewing what you’ve had for years, our team is here to help—without the pressure. Give us a call, stop by the office in West Middlesex, or use our easy online tool to compare quotes in minutes.