Coverage That Fits Real Life

Personal Insurance for Pennsylvania & Ohio

When it comes to protecting the people, property, and plans that matter most, you want coverage that makes sense—not just something that checks a box. At Rodgers & Co Insurance in West Middlesex, PA, we help individuals and families across Mercer, Lawrence, Trumbull, and Mahoning Counties get insurance that’s actually built around how they live.



Whether you’re insuring your car, your house, your boat, or your future, we make the process straightforward and personal—just like it should be.

We Help You Protect What You’ve Worked Hard For

From apartments in Hermitage to lake homes near Pymatuning, from first-time drivers to retirees, Rodgers & Co has helped thousands of people get the coverage they need without overpaying for what they don’t.


Our personal insurance options include:

Independent Advice from a Local Insurance Team

We’re not a big-box agency or an online-only quoting engine. As a family-owned independent insurance agency, we live and work where our clients do—and we understand what coverage people in Western PA and Eastern OH actually need.


Why people stick with us:

Black check mark on a white background

Over 28 years of insurance experience

Black check mark icon on a white background

Access to multiple top-rated carriers, not just one

Black check mark on a white background

Licensed in both PA and OH

Black check mark on a white background

One-on-one help with claims, questions, and updates

Black check mark on a white background

Small-town service with big-agency capabilities

From Sharon to Youngstown, we’re known for keeping things simple, honest, and helpful.

Bundle & Save on Your Personal Coverage

Want to save on premiums without cutting corners? We’ll show you how to bundle policies together and qualify for discounts.


Ask us about:

Black check mark on a white background

Multi-policy savings (auto + home, auto + renters, etc.)

Black check mark on a white background

Safe driver and good student discounts

Black checkmark on a white background

Pay-in-full and paperless billing options

Black check mark on a white background

Low-mileage and usage-based programs

Black check mark on a white background

Preferred carrier loyalty programs

Visit our Auto Insurance Savings Tips › to learn more, or just ask—we’ll walk you through it.

How to Get a Personal Insurance Quote

Whether you’re starting fresh or reviewing your current coverage, getting a quote is simple.



Here’s how it works:

Black phone handset icon with ringing signal lines

Tell us what you’re looking for

Use our online form or give us a call.

Document with magnifying glass icon, black outline on white background

We compare options across carriers

 Because we’re independent, we can shop around for you.

Three hands pointing inward in a circle, outlined with a dotted ring.

You choose what fits

We’ll walk you through every option so you can make confident choices.

FAQs About Personal Insurance Coverage

  • Can I bundle auto and home insurance to save money?

    Yes! Most carriers offer a multi-policy discount, and it’s one of the easiest ways to save on both premiums. We’ll compare bundled options and show you what works best.

  • Does home insurance cover flood damage?

    No. Standard homeowners policies don’t cover damage from rising water. If you’re near a creek, low-lying area, or have a finished basement, we’ll talk you through flood coverage options.

  • Can you help with insurance for motorcycles or boats?

     Absolutely. We insure motorcycles, boats, jet skis, RVs, and more. Whether it’s stored for the season or on the road, we’ll find a policy that fits your lifestyle and usage.

  • Is an umbrella policy worth it?

    If you own a home, have teen drivers, or simply want more liability protection, an umbrella policy is a smart add-on. It’s typically inexpensive and offers extra peace of mind.

Still not sure what kind of coverage fits your needs? Reach out and we’ll help you sort it out.

Protect What Matters Most—Without the Guesswork

At Rodgers & Co Insurance, we don’t sell insurance—we help you build it. Let’s talk about what matters to you, and we’ll make sure you’re covered.